Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ian Weinberg's avatar

A fascinating article dealing with a very complex subject. It is an issue steeped in passionate emotions, both positive and negative, with a history spanning more than three thousand years. As a Jew by birth, my inquiry never ceases: What is the essence of a Jew? What is the fundamental cause of anti-semitism through the ages? What were the prevailing factors that contributed to the Jewish religion/culture/identity and ultimately to Zionism as a nationalistic movement and the establishment of the State of Israel as a Jewish homeland? For me, one item stands as a defining concept as initiating all subsequent events: The exile of the Jews of Judah and Samaria to Babylon cemented their religious and cultural beliefs, incorporating the subjective belief in their 'Chosen People' status. It was this collective identity which was subsequently carried to Rome with the Roman exile and then across Europe. The rest, as they say, is history. Maintaining a separate identity colored with the 'Chosen People' status created an aversion to assimilation. Inevitably the separateness and exclusivity of the group elicited animosity, disparaging judgementalism leading to anti-semitism in all its forms. The 'us-you' divisions were generationally re-enforced, culminating initially in the need for the Zionistic movement and then the Holocaust. These phenomena converged into the establishment of the State of Israel. Prior to the establishment of Israel, the concept that you quoted by the Rothchild's is pivotal: To endeavour to put an end to the wandering Jew without creating the wandering Arab! The Jewish pioneers of the Jewish state were essentially Westerners. They were no longer the original Jewish semites that had lived side by side with their Arab neighbours. And so there was a culture clash aggravating the possession of the land. Thereafter a new course of actions and reactions occurred, fomenting the current crisis. The questions remain: What is a Jew? What is the value of a sustained and separate Jewish identity going forward other than a respect for history and heritage? Still much work in progress. For me the Chosen People are folk of all races and religions that contribute value to civilization, guided by sensitivity and humility.

Expand full comment
striketheroot's avatar

IMHO to understand this whole subject one needs to research the creators of the Talmud, the Torah, and the ancient Babylonian and Indo Asian texts, (most which have never been translated) and dig deep into the fantastic stories that abound world wide regarding our NON HUMAN progenitors, (probably HOMO CAPENSIS) who sold themselves as gods to their genetically modified creations. A good place to start is the Vatican researcher /translator Mauro Biglino. The story behind the jewish superiority "attitude" is far deeper than anyone can imagine: "History is written by the victors" (not the slaves).

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts